What Is a Policy Cycle?
First, what is a policy? A policy and procedure are two distinct entities. A policy sets the course of action selected from alternatives, in light of the conditions that should guide present and future decisions.
So, what is a policy cycle? It is the repeatable process an organization uses to set a policy agenda, write policy, implement policy, enforce policy, and review policy before the next round of change begins.
What Is a Policy Cycle?
A policy cycle is the structured path a policy follows from initial need to review and renewal. It keeps policy from becoming a one-time document exercise. Instead, policy becomes a living management system that can adjust as objectives, resources, risks, and operating realities change.
Organizations typically have high-level and low-level policies. High-level policies govern the entire company in most or all circumstances. They are somewhat generalized and often articulate soft goals, company desires, needs, and aspirations. High-level policy does not readily lend itself to procedures; instead, it often takes the form of a standard or guideline.
Low-level policy deals with a more specific set of circumstances. It is the kind that usually leads to procedures. An attendance policy is a familiar example: employees are expected to be available for work during normal working hours, and the related procedure explains how time is recorded, absences are reported, and exceptions are approved.
Because the world around us continually changes, policies, especially high-level policies, have to be reviewed and reshaped occasionally. The policy cycle gives that review a disciplined rhythm instead of waiting until a noticeable event or trend forces the organization to respond.
What Does the Policy Cycle Consist Of?
The policy cycle usually includes five practical stages: setting the policy agenda, writing policy, implementing policy, enforcing policy, and reviewing policy. These stages look sequential on paper, but in practice they often overlap. The CDC notes that policy development is rarely a linear process, which is also true inside companies.
That matters because business policy is not written in a vacuum. A policy may begin with a compliance issue, a process breakdown, a customer complaint, a new technology, or a change in company strategy. The policy cycle helps the organization decide which issues deserve attention, how the policy should be written, and when it needs to be revisited.
Setting the Policy Agenda
Your organization has limited resources: time, money, people, executive attention, and operational capacity. Whatever your company’s intent, whatever its objectives and strategy, you can only do so much at once. Your policy agenda is a concession to the scarcity of resources.
What resources you have, you manage well and you prioritize. A useful agenda separates urgent policy work from merely interesting policy work. It also makes localized interests visible, so a department’s preferred agenda item does not quietly crowd out a company-wide need.
The smaller the organization, the easier it is to start the policy cycle. In larger organizations, we often see more intense competition to politicize an agenda. Preferred items get on the agenda because they serve familiar local interests, which are easier to understand and deal with, rather than the broader interests of the entire company.
Writing Policy
Writing policy is a major part of the policy cycle because a policy has to be easy to understand and implement. New business policy statements should be clear, concise, and direct. Policies should not be open to interpretation, though this is not always possible, especially with high-level policies.
When interpretation is unavoidable, the company should identify policy experts who are readily available to interpret policy and resolve differences. Otherwise, a policy can look complete in a manual while still creating inconsistent decisions in the field.
Policy writing should be an iterative process. Policy drafts should be reviewed by a representative sample of the group or groups that will be responsible for implementing the policy on a daily basis. Those reviewers often spot conflicts, missing definitions, unclear responsibilities, and exceptions that the first drafter did not see.
Implementing Policy
People have to know that a policy exists if they are to be held accountable for it. They also need to know why the policy exists. People generally view policies as restrictions, and unless it is clear where and why the policy originated, compliance will be a problem in this part of the policy cycle.
Policies have to be communicated effectively, and there needs to be a suitable introductory period to ensure compliance. Give people advance notice. Give them time to learn the policy, discuss it with others, understand it, and submit their comments.
When people feel they have had a say in policy, they are more likely to comply. That does not mean every employee gets veto power. It means the organization treats implementation as communication, training, acknowledgement, and practical adoption, not just publication of a new document.
Enforcing Policy
Given that policies are often developed in response to problems, how do you make sure the problem does not recur? You try not to make policy that is unenforceable. An unenforceable policy tells employees that the organization is willing to write rules it cannot, or will not, support.
A policy has to be clear on what constitutes compliance and what happens in the event of noncompliance. There has to be clear responsibility for ensuring compliance and imposing penalties. Without ownership, enforcement becomes personal preference instead of a standard company practice.
This is why unenforceable policies are so damaging. They do not merely fail to solve the original problem. They also weaken trust in the next policy the organization asks people to follow.
Reviewing and Updating Policy
Policies are often changed only because a noticeable event or trend occurred and forced the organization to respond. That is exactly what the review stage is meant to prevent. A good policy cycle creates planned review points, so the company notices changes before they become emergencies.
The majority of company policies, once written and implemented, are rarely looked at again. Yet the reviewing part of the policy cycle is needed to ensure that policies reflect the business realities of the moment. Technology changes, staffing models change, customer expectations change, and risk changes.
Consider a company that builds policy around a product line, a supplier relationship, or a technology platform that later becomes less useful. If the company never reevaluates its policy, it may keep optimizing for conditions that no longer exist. You either change, or you have change forced on you.
What about your organization? When was the last time you reviewed any of your policy manual? Do you follow a policy cycle, or do policies only change after a problem becomes too visible to ignore?
Download free policies and procedures in easy to edit Microsoft Word templates to quickly and easily create your own policy and procedure manual using Bizmanualz policy and procedure templates.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is a Policy Cycle?
A policy cycle is the repeatable process an organization uses to identify a policy need, write the policy, implement it, enforce it, and review it for future updates.
Why Is the Policy Cycle Important?
The policy cycle is important because it keeps policies current, practical, and enforceable. Without a cycle, policies often become outdated documents that no longer match the way the business operates.
What Are the Main Stages of the Policy Cycle?
The main stages are setting the policy agenda, writing policy, implementing policy, enforcing policy, and reviewing or updating policy. The stages may overlap, but each one answers a different management question.
How Often Should Policies Be Reviewed?
Policies should be reviewed on a planned schedule and whenever a major business, legal, technology, or risk change occurs. The right cadence depends on the policy’s impact and the pace of change in the area it governs.
What Makes a Policy Hard to Enforce?
A policy is hard to enforce when it is unclear, unrealistic, poorly communicated, or missing an owner. It also becomes difficult to enforce when the organization has not defined what compliance looks like.
